handcuff

ARRESTED? INVESTIGATED?

ARRESTADO? INVESTIGADO?

handcuff
Albert Quirantes Miami Criminal Attorneys

Can Parents Be Held Responsible for a Child’s Crime in Florida? Restitution, Costs and Firearm Liability

Share:

Albert Quirantes reviews paperwork and a photograph of a cracked window with a parent.

Your son is in trouble, and now you are hearing two completely different things. A neighbour says you will have to pay for everything he broke. A relative says parents can never be responsible for what their kids do.

Both are wrong, because both are too simple. Florida has specific rules for juvenile restitution, civil property claims and an adult’s own conduct around firearms. The first step is figuring out which kind of responsibility someone is actually claiming.

Four different things that get lumped together

A restitution order in the juvenile case, a civil lawsuit, court costs and a criminal accusation against a parent are separate matters. Each has its own rules, its own procedure and its own defenses. Our Miami juvenile defense page explains your child’s case. You may also need advice about anything aimed at you personally.

Restitution follows the child’s offense

Florida Statute 985.437 allows the juvenile court to order restitution for damage or loss caused by the child’s offense, in a reasonable amount or manner set by the court. It also limits the amount to what the child and parent or guardian could reasonably be expected to pay or make.

That is not a blank check for whatever a victim claims. Ask for repair estimates, photos, ownership information and anything else supporting the loss. Ask how each item connects to the offense. Your lawyer should review value and causation before your family agrees to a number you do not understand.

A parent’s good-faith efforts can matter

Section 985.437(4) provides that if the court finds at a hearing that the parent or guardian made diligent and good-faith efforts to prevent the child from engaging in delinquent acts, the parent or guardian is absolved of restitution liability under that section.

The court needs proof, not just a parent’s sincere belief. Keep honest records of supervision, school meetings, counseling and what you did when earlier problems came up. Never create records after the fact or ask a provider to exaggerate. Talk with the lawyer about which records help and how to handle sensitive information.

A civil claim is a separate road

Florida Statute 741.24 allows a civil lawsuit against the parents of a minor under 18 who lives with them and who maliciously or willfully destroys or steals someone else’s property. Recovery under that statute is limited to actual damages plus taxable court costs. You may hear people repeat a fixed dollar cap. The statute’s text does not contain one.

A demand letter is not a court judgment. The person making the claim still needs a legal basis and facts to support it. Give your lawyer the complete letter and any proposed agreement before you sign.

Property damage deserves a close look

A cracked phone, a broken window or spray paint on a wall can lead to arguments over repair costs and who did what. Our criminal mischief defense page explains the underlying offense. A label like “vandalism” does not prove every dollar on the invoice.

Gather photos of the original condition, repair records and anything identifying other people involved. Do not pressure witnesses. Before paying, ask whether the payment resolves the claim completely, whether it includes an admission and whether other claims could still follow.

Firearm access can create a parent’s own charge

This is where parents face personal criminal exposure. Under Florida Statute 790.22(4)(a), a parent, guardian or other responsible adult who knowingly and willfully permits a minor to possess a firearm in violation of the law commits a third-degree felony. For an adult, that carries up to five years in state prison under Florida Statute 775.082.

That charge is about the adult’s own conduct and state of mind. Being a parent is not enough. If investigators ask who gave your child the gun or allowed access, get legal advice before you answer in detail. Your child’s lawyer does not automatically represent you, and you may need separate counsel when your interests and your child’s could differ. Our article on teen gun charges covers your child’s side of that case.

Safe storage is a different statute

Florida Statute 790.174 addresses storing a loaded firearm where a minor can get it, and makes it a second-degree misdemeanor when the failure leads to specified access and possession or display. For this statute, “minor” means someone younger than 16. That is a different age than the under-18 rule in section 790.22, and the two should never be blended.

How the gun was stored, how the child got to it and what happened next all matter. A parent is not automatically guilty whenever a child touches a firearm. Lawful ownership does not answer a storage accusation either.

Lawyers for your child, and advice for you

When a parent’s own exposure is on the table, both the juvenile case and adult criminal law come into play. Stephen Millan, Esq. is a former Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge who presided over hundreds of criminal and juvenile cases, and a former Miami-Dade Assistant State Attorney. Arthur Spiegel, Esq. is a former Miami-Dade Assistant Public Defender in the juvenile and criminal divisions who has represented hundreds of juveniles in criminal cases, with more than 40 years of experience. Jorge E. Alonso, Esq. has defended the accused in Miami-Dade state and federal courts for more than 40 years, has tried more than 100 jury trials to verdict and has represented juvenile respondents in delinquency cases. Jonathan Ibáñez, Esq., a bilingual criminal defense trial lawyer and a native of South Florida, served as a volunteer Guardian ad Litem in Broward County, where he interviewed children and families and advocated for children in dependency proceedings. Albert Quirantes, Esq. is a criminal trial lawyer with 38 years of experience who has defended numerous juvenile cases in Miami-Dade County. See our attorneys page.

If a payment is proposed, ask for the written order or legal basis, who owes it, the amount and how to request a hearing. If an agreement names both you and your child, have the lawyer explain each signature line before you sign. If restitution later becomes a probation issue, our article on juvenile probation violations explains what can happen.

For more information or help, schedule a free strategy session at the law offices of Albert Quirantes, Esq. Criminal DUI & Ticket Lawyers. Text or call 305-644-1800 now.

Share:

Recent Posts

Send Us A Message